Bishop to Boycott Obama Commencement Speech
2009 College Grads: We're the Lucky Ones
Why there is hope for the graduating Class of 2009, and how they can find work in a recession...Read the postBeer in Vending Machines -- What Drinking Age?
U.S. policies on drinking age seem restrictive when examining the rest of the world...Read the postHow The Press Can Remain Relevant
Is it any surprise that Obama has employed a strategy to cordon journalists that is similar to previous administrations?...Read the postBe Afraid, Cheney Warns. Be Very Afraid.
Just when you thought the Bush-era warnings of Armageddon around the corner were over, Cheney strikes again...Read the postObama: You Wouldn't Like Me When I'm Angry...
Obama threw down his stick, spat on the floor and growled in the face of cameras -- metaphorically... Read the postObama to GOP: 'I Won, I'm The President'
"You can't just listen to Rush Limbaugh and get things done," Obama told GOP leaders...Read the postPalin Seeks $11M Book Deal, but Can She Read?
One can only imagine what Republican rising star Sarah Palin could possibly write about in her memoirs...Read the postpoliticsculture
Debate Over Obama Notre Dame Commencement Address Heats Up
Posted: Mar 24th 2009 1:03AM
Filed under: Politics, Small Campus, Big Story, Culture, Religion, Breaking News, News, Local, Notre Dame
The White House and Notre Dame announced last Friday that President Barack Obama would be the main speaker at the May 17 Commencement ceremony and would be awarded an honorary doctor of laws degree, a decision that has caused controversy among many in the Catholic community.
Though many students and alums of the University are pleased to have the president speak at Commencement, those opposed to the decision have been far more vocal, as students, alumni and people not affiliated with Notre Dame voiced their protestations loudly throughout the Internet and in Notre Dame's student newspaper.
Fr. John Jenkins, the president of Notre Dame, gave an interview to The Observer, the student newspaper, Sunday in which he responded to the criticism and said he did not "foresee" circumstances in which Notre Dame would rescind the invitation to the president. (Full disclosure: I work for The Observer.)
"We have invited the president and he's honored us by accepting," he told The Observer.
There's been an uproar about the decision, judging by letters to the editor, blog posts and petitions, due to Obama's pro-abortion stances. Jenkins defended his choice, saying the invitation to Obama does not signify an endorsement.
"The invitation of President Obama to be our Commencement speaker should in no way be taken as condoning or endorsing his positions on specific issues regarding the protection of life, such as abortion and embryonic stem cell research," Jenkins told The Observer.
The protestations against the choice of Obama have been very loud, especially in the opinion section of The Observer, but it should be noted that in a mock election held by Notre Dame's student government last October, Obama won 52.6 percent of the vote compared to McCain's 41.1 percent.
Not everyone is protesting Obama coming to campus; many are thrilled. A Facebook group titled "We Will Be Honored To Have President Obama at Notre Dame" has 1,389 members. Several Facebook groups, however, have been created to protest Obama as Commencement speaker.
All I wanted was a nice, quiet, peaceful graduation day, a time to celebrate with my family and friends, without posters of aborted fetuses. Such a simple request. But it won't be so.
Already, pro-life activists are making plans to come to South Bend to protest.
A Web site called notredamescandal.com has set up an online petition to ask Jenkins to rescind the invitation, saying it is in violation of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops' 2004 document called "Catholics in Political Life," which states that "those who act in defiance of our fundamental moral principles" "should not be given awards, honors or platforms which would suggest support for their actions" by Catholic institutions.
The Web site, launched by the Cardinal Newman Society, claims it has nearly 48,000 signatures. The Cardinal Newman Society, established in 1993, is "dedicated to renewing and strengthening Catholic identity at America's 224 Catholic colleges and universities," according to its Web site.
National Review Online, the Web site of the conservative magazine, asked various commentators to give their views on Notre Dame's speaker choice.
It's become popular in American discourse to invoke Hitler when making a point about something one views as egregious. On National Review's Web site, Fr. George W. Rutler, a Catholic priest in New York, skipped that tiresome cliche and brought back an oldie:
"If a Midwestern school seeks attention by granting Obama an honorary doctorate in law, the next logical step would be to grant Judas Iscariot posthumously an honorary doctorate in business administration," he wrote.
This is only day three of the Great Obama Debate; there is no end in sight. Outside the Notre Dame bubble, I'm sure, no one is talking about the Obama Commencement speaker choice. But it's hard to see reality beyond the bubble while on campus. Here, it is the primary topic of conversation.
Anecdotally, I'd say most seniors I've talked to are excited about Obama coming to speak at graduation. But those who are against Obama speaking are making a lot more noise in the student paper and on the Internet.
My advice to Fr. Jenkins is to fire Charlie Weis and re-hire Ty Willingham. There's nothing like breaking football news to change the topic of conversation at Notre Dame.
Join The Discussion
Categories
Most Popular Stories »
- Macys thanksgiving day history
- Students for Justice in Palestine: A real look inside
- Suspects Arrested in Murder of Student
- New Moon an improvement in Twilight saga
- Thanksgiving-themed movies are a hard-to-find but not impossible genre









Recent Comments »
Page 1/3
Post Your Comments Below
| 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 20 Comments
pete staff
7:30AM 7:30AM Mar 24th 2009
When will the roman church die hards. find and other issue than abortion. Thier dark age beliefs should stay in the a dark ages.
Rating :
Reply to this commentReport!
anne
10:30AM 10:30AM Mar 24th 2009
Seems to me murdering innocent babies for the mother's "convienence " is pretty much dark age thinking.
Rating :
Report!
falling
3:04PM 3:04PM Mar 24th 2009
I have no church affiliation at all, in fact I would call myself an agnostic...but killing your own child is a pretty dark ages thing to do if you ask me! Morality DOES extend beyond the church...it just doesn't seem to extend to the Democrat party!
Rating :
Report!
Carol
4:24PM 4:24PM Mar 27th 2009
Women in this country need to acquire some self-respect, meaning keep their legs closed, to prevent unwanted pregnancy which will lead to their "choice" to kill the unwanted infant. Morality has taken the back road. Anything goes these days and the innocent pay the price.
Rating :
Report!
Jeanie
11:01PM 11:01PM Apr 1st 2009
It is as important of an issue in our lives as the right to love your mother and father, brother and sister is to you, and you would never want to see harm done to them. A baby is the most precious thing God put on this earth. What will most of these people do if our government decides that we are over populated and can not afford to feed them and then demands you have an abortion? There are some things no matter how old and dark ages they are that may one day be the very thing you will depend on.
Rating :
Report!
Ed
3:56PM 3:56PM Apr 3rd 2009
Judging from your grammar and spelling, you are still in the Dark Ages. Thank you for the pathetic attempt at enlightenment.
Rating :
Report!
Willet
9:26AM 9:26AM Mar 24th 2009
There's some opportunity here for Notre Dame. Next year they can invite Congressman Barney Frank to give the Commencement Address and then give him an honorary Ph.D in Theology from the Humanities Department.
Rating :
Reply to this commentReport!
moderate
9:29AM 9:29AM Mar 24th 2009
Abortion is a legal medical procedure and stem cell has never been banned. The republicans had control of the government and did nothing about abortion, the reason being the majority of americans believe a women not agovernment or church has the right to tell her what to do with her body. Stem cell research, never banned by bush or republicans, why, the ability to find cures for terrible diseases that affict actual humans not cells.
Rating :
Reply to this commentReport!
anne
10:36AM 10:36AM Mar 24th 2009
It doen't matter what YOU think---Catholics belive abortion is murder. Notre Dame is a CATHOLIC school. People go there and supportit because it is Catholic. If the school wants that support they shouldn't invite the most radically pro abortion president ever.
Rating :
Report!
widwid60
3:03PM 3:03PM Mar 24th 2009
You started as cells.
Rating :
Report!
falling
3:05PM 3:05PM Mar 24th 2009
Actually, Republican's never had more than a one vote lead in the Senate so they were never able to PASS much legislation against abortion, but they definitely TRIED multiple times! I'm not sure why liberals are so set on convincing mothers to kill their unborn children, but the Catholic church has NEVER thought is was open for debate! I know that and I have never even set foot in a church of any kind!
Rating :
Report!
nick
10:05AM 10:05AM Mar 24th 2009
If this happens this will be the last time I give a chunk of money to the colleage, this ass hole doesn't value the child one bit, he said one time it was beyond his paygrade but it didn't take the ass hole very long to side with the abortion folks, anything to suck up to his voter base.
Rating :
Reply to this commentReport!
anne
10:40AM 10:40AM Mar 24th 2009
It doen't matter what YOU think---Catholics believe abortion is murder--by the way %60 of American think that, not just Catholics. Anyway Notre Dame is a CATHOLIC school. People go there and
support it because it is Catholic. If the school wants that support they shouldn't invite the most radically pro abortion president ever.
Rating :
Reply to this commentReport!
moderate
11:59AM 11:59AM Mar 24th 2009
no one is pro abortion they are pro choice. And i am intitled to an opinion, People can not tell anyone to shut up because they disagree about a legal medical procedure.
Rating :
Report!
g
8:42AM 8:42AM Mar 25th 2009
I can assure you without any doubt that CATHOLIC WOMEN HAVE ABORTIONS!
Ask those of us who are Ob-Gyns!
Rating :
Report!
Winston Smith
10:47AM 10:47AM Mar 24th 2009
nick: If this happens this will be the last time I give a chunk of money to the colleage, this ass hole doesn't value the child one bit, he said one time it was beyond his paygrade but it didn't take the ass hole very long to side with the abortion folks, anything to suck up to his voter base.
------------------------------------------------
Sure Nicky Boy.
As IF you gave a "chunk of money" to any "colleage" -ever.
It appears YOU didn't even make it through Elementary School.
Rating :
Reply to this commentReport!
Steve
10:59AM 10:59AM Mar 24th 2009
I don't agree with abortion, all Obama is working at is getting a second term. He and his wife are just looking to be the fairytail family in the White House.
On Sunday Obama called The White House, "Good Diggs".
I don't think our Founding Fathers would approve of calling the most important building in the US such slang.
Obama knows if he can suck-up to the right people he may be able to win a second term. Everyone looking for a hand-out will be voting for him.
This Country was not built with "Hand-Outs". It was created with hard work, and citizens making sacrifices.
Most young kids now want to have "stacks" and diamond earrings, platinum & gold, wheels that spin when the car is stopped, tires so large they belong on tractors.
"Throw your hands in the air, like you just don't care"
is the new generation national anthem.
This country is in trouble, big trouble.
Rating :
Reply to this commentReport!
Magic 8
11:02AM 11:02AM Mar 24th 2009
I guess Paris Hilton wasn't available?
ND is a disgrace...
Rating :
Reply to this commentReport!
neil
11:15AM 11:15AM Mar 24th 2009
nick
how many babies have you adopted ?
nick i sure you have enough problems in your life..leave people alone..
until you step up to the plate and start adopting some of these unwanted babies..then you can say something
Rating :
Reply to this commentReport!
Magic 8
11:34AM 11:34AM Mar 24th 2009
Tell Father Jenkins what you think:
http://president.nd.edu/contact-us
Rating :
Reply to this commentReport!
| 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 20 Comments